Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Patent litigation in Europe: Can start-ups and growth companies defend their rights?

Research output: Thesis › Doctoral Thesis › Collection of Articles

Abstract

The patent regime should provide adequate measures when start-ups and growth
companies are accused of or receive threats for infringing patent holder’s rights.
Fighting against infringements is a financial burden that eventually hinders a com-
pany’s growth. This is more damaging to smaller companies. Patents can also be
asserted inappropriately; such assertions infringe on the functions of patents, and
deliberately go beyond the claims and boundaries of what is protected.
The research established three preliminary aspects for discussion. First, start-
ups and growth companies have a central role in innovations activities. Second, the
European patent enforcement scene has to address both the cross-border exploita-
tion of patents and the unitary patent system regime that is coming into force. Third,
start-ups and growth companies must be able to retaliate against infringements with
adequate measures.
Patents are seen as an important economic tool with potentially significant com-
mercial value. As a corollary, their use has broadened and diversified. Thus, patent
related transactions have increased and new structures and ways of monetizing pat-
ents have emerged as patent funds. Patent funds bring opportunities as they are able
to monetize patents and to finance companies; however, they also cause difficulties
and litigation is used as a threat to obtain financial compensation. In addition, patent
laws and their applications are challenged by the growing interdependence of various
entities in different countries.
The question addressed throughout the whole research is: How can efficiency
and legal certainty be increased through patent enforcement regulations so that the
European patent enforcement regime supports start-ups and growth companies?
Legal certainty and efficiency have been determined as the normative goals for this
research and the perspective applied is that of the New Institutional Economics (NIE)
and comparative law. NIE studies how institutions interact with organisations where
both are interactive by nature. The legal institutions recognised are the relevant rules
and case law and the organizations are entities such as companies and patent funds.
The institutional environment establishes the general framework in which the insti-
tutional arrangements occur.
This dissertation examines procedural safeguards such as fee shifting,
5
preliminary injunctions and bifurcation. It also investigates the multiple defendants’
rule. Furthermore, the abuse of rights principle, the abuse of dominant position, the
IP Enforcement Directive and unjustified threats are examined. In this research, the
relevant legal institutions are the European Union law and the legislation of selected
European countries. The focus is mainly on Germany, the United Kingdom and the
Netherlands as these countries deal with the majority of European patent cases.
The measures studied in this dissertation provide tools for start-ups and growth
companies when defending their rights. As regards certain of these tools, coherence
in the judicial interpretation has been achieved. However, the adequacy of these tools
from a legal certainty and efficiency point of view can be criticised. In addition, the
complexity of these measures and the uncertainty of the unitary patent regime will
reduce their potential to act as safeguards. Thus, it must be acknowledged that the
goal of legal certainty, as stated in the patent regime’s aim to promote innovation
activities for start-ups and growth companies, has not been fully achieved.
Original languageEnglish
QualificationDoctor of Laws
Awarding Institution
  • University of Turku
Award date26.11.2021
Publisher
Print ISBNs978-951-29-8566-1
Electronic ISBNs978-951-29-8567-8
Publication statusPublished - 2021
MoE publication typeG5 Doctoral dissertation (article)

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Patent litigation in Europe: Can start-ups and growth companies defend their rights?'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this